I figured it out. Realizing this is a older game I updated my GamersFirst pass to be less complex, I was then able to log right in to the launcher with my GamersFirst account. Heads up for anyone else having this issue.
Hey All,
Just signed up to play classic and getting an auth error. The only login I have is the Gamersfirst and I cannot seem to find anywhere to create a FE specific login. Anyone know what I am doing wrong?